Mitt Romney’s Medicare Problem
January 29th, 2012Former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney is expected to win the Florida primary on Tuesday. Political pundits are saying that this would just about insure that Romney will be the Republican presidential nominee for 2012, although the pundits have been wrong before.
The last post looked at how Newt Gingrich’s past association with Medicare Part D is being used against him in the campaign. Now Florida television viewers are seeing ads accusing Mitt Romney of Medicare fraud. Could that be true? Here’s the story:
Back in 1989, the private equity firm Bain Capital purchased the Damon Corp., a medical testing company based in Needham, Massachusetts. Mitt Romney was head of Bain Capital at the time. In 1991 Damon became a publicly traded company, and Mitt Romney was on its board of directors. In 1993, Bain sold Damon to another company, Corning, at a nice profit.
However, in October 1996 Damon plead guilty to Medicare fraud and agreed to pay fines of $119 million. Federal prosecutors said that from 1988 to 1993 Damon had been billing Medicare for tests that had not been done. This was going on the entire time that Damon had been owned and managed by Mitt Romney’s company, Bain. Corning, not Bain, was given credit for discovering the fraud and putting a stop to it.
Mr. Romney was never personally implicated in the fraud, and today he says he knew nothing about it. However, the Damon Corp. fraud case came up in 2002, when Romney was running for governor of Massachusetts. According to ABC News, Romney said at that time that he had found out about the fraud and had “blown the whistle” on it, but it’s not clear that statement is true, either.
The issue of Medicare fraud is especially sensitive to Florida voters, and not just because almost one in five Floridians is retired. The current governor of Florida, Rick Scott, was once CEO of a company that was later convicted of Medicare fraud. Scott himself was not prosecuted. But Florida has not been happy with Gov. Scott; recent polls have found as few as 26 percent of Floridians approving of him.
Some anti-Romney television ads show Romney’s face morphing into Scott’s, to remind voters what happened the last time they voted for a politician connected to Medicare fraud. Whether this will resonate with Florida voters remains to be seen.
Mr. Romney has another Medicare problem, however. According to the Tampa Bay Times, “Florida Republican voters have a clear feeling about cuts to Medicare and Social Security: Don’t do it, according to a new poll by the AARP.”
Retirees understand how much they depend on the Medicare program, and this is true whether the retirees are healthy or suffering life-threatening illnesses such as mesothelioma, usually diagnosed in people aged 50 or over. And they want the program left alone.
But according to the Family Practice News, a journal for family practice physicians,
“Although his platform makes no overt mention of Medicare, analysis by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities noted that, if enacted, Mr. Romney’s proposal to cap total spending and balance the budget would lead to a 17%-24% cut to Medicare by 2016.”
It’s not clear if anyone is explaining this to Florida voters, however.

