Off-Roaders Say Asbestos Not Dangerous at Clear Creek
May 8th, 2008Off-road aficionados who frequent the 31,000-acre area known as Clear Creek, located near Hollister, Calif., are angry that the state has closed their favorite recreation spot.
California’s Bureau of Land Management closed about half the Clear Creek Management Area in the Diablo Range last week following a report by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) noting that asbestos in the area posed a serious cancer risk to those who work, hike, camp, hunt, collect gems and ride dirt bikes there. Officials will explain their findings tonight at a meeting at the Santa Clara Convention Center, notes an article in the San Francisco Chronicle.
“Clear Creek contains the largest deposits of asbestos in the United States because of its unique combination of faults and volcanic rock,” said Arnold Den, a senior science adviser for the EPA. Though no studies have been conducted among those who frequently dirt bike there, a 2005 University of California (Davis) study found that people living near naturally-occurring asbestos had a significantly higher cancer rate than those who don’t. Asbestos can cause a fatal, aggressive form of cancer known as malignant mesothelioma. The disease is common among tradesmen who worked with asbestos on a regular basis.
The article notes that hundreds of off-road enthusiasts head to Clear Creek each weekend when the weather is pleasant. Most think the type of asbestos found at the recreation area is not toxic and they can’t understand why the state would deny them access to Clear Creek.
“The recreation community is in a state of shock,” said Don Amador, a frequent visitor to Clear Creek and the Western representative for the Blue Ribbon Coalition, an off-road advocacy group.
“It’s unprecedented, as far as public land issues go. We’re going to want to fight it, either administratively or in court.”
No “Clear Creek regulars” have become sick because of asbestos exposure, Amador added.
“We’re asked our friends and family in the off-road community if they’ve heard of anyone getting mesothelioma, and we haven’t found one case,” he said.



